Article Teaching Students to Critique
Helping your students learn how to creatively critique each other's work.
Humans are social creatures and being a member of a group is a good description of the human experience. And because working with others is an essential skill to learn, collaboration has been identified as a 21st-century workplace ability as well as a component of the Common Core State Standards. Given that the performing arts are primarily group experiences, the arts become a prime tool for building skills in collaboration.
What is Collaboration?
In collaborative learning, students work together to accomplish a shared goal. In this regard, it is similar to cooperative learning. Educator Olga Kozar highlights an important difference between collaboration and cooperation, which is the process. In cooperative learning, students work independently on their own tasks that contribute to the final product. But in collaborative learning, students’ work is intertwined throughout the process, resulting in a product that many hands have made.
Drawing on the work of Roger Johnson and David Johnson, two educators (and brothers) from the University of Minnesota, here are six tips to start creating successful collaborations.
Getting started. First, successful collaboration involves learning several key skills; so be prepared for students to neet time and instruction to learn how to collaborate. Plan for time to teach these skills in addition to the arts content. Next, create a structure within which students will work. Establish procedures and expectations for collaborative work. In the arts, the rehearsal setting creates a framework for students to work collaboratively. Its structure, rules, roles, and etiquette can help create clarity about outcomes and expectations. And if your students are new to collaboration, start simply and have them begin working with a partner. When they accomplish that, move them on to small groups.
We are all in this together. When collaborating, students are interdependent; they depend on each other to succeed. Every student in a collaborative group needs an understanding of their group’s goal and how they contribute to it. When learning collaboratively, students will benefit from time spent planning and identifying roles or jobs, such as set designer, performer, conductor, or composer. Seeing the connections between jobs helps build reliance on each other.
Lend a helping hand. It’s no wonder that music, dance, and theater all use the word “ensemble” to refer to a group working together. Students must learn that they need to help each other to meet the ensemble's goals and that competition within a collaborative group doesn't work. Students working collaboratively often end up teaching others something they have mastered. Helping someone else learn a choreographed sequence or the blocking for a scene reinforces one’s own knowledge and skills.
Do your part. When collaborating, students take responsibility for, and are personally accountable to, the ensemble. And no doubt, members of an ensemble all have responsibility for the group’s success. Every member has something unique to accomplish. In addition, each member is obliged to get the work done. This is seen most clearly in performance—which is the ultimate accountability for an ensemble.
Play well with others. Effective collaborators are respectful and listen to each other. They may not always agree, but they recognize that listening is the first step to working out a difference. Working with students on their listening skills helps engage them artistically with other students. For example, student actors come to realize that acting is as much (and maybe more) about listening as it is about speaking. Musicians are also actively listening to each other as they play together. Becoming active listeners also sharpens students in their role as audience members and viewers of art. When students reflect on and assess their collaborative work, respect for and listening to others are important criteria.
Think it over. With their collaborators, students can reflect on the successes and challenges their ensemble encountered, as well as changes they wish to make in the future. Collaboration inherently involves feedback and reflection, so prep students with the skills to give, receive, and use peer feedback. Working collaboratively means that part of the learning process is to create a safe space for mistakes and even failure.
Collaboration is a foundational element of the performing arts. “People in a good collaboration accomplish more than the group’s most talented members can achieve on their own,” wrote choreographer Twyla Tharp. Collaboration is a powerful instructional tool to help students think beyond themselves and learn in deep and meaningful ways.
Writer
Patti Saraniero
Editor
Lisa Resnick
Producer
Joanna McKee
Updated
October 8, 2019
Sources
Helping your students learn how to creatively critique each other's work.
Process drama is an imaginative tool for non-arts teachers and students to explore issues and solve problems.
Explore ways to handle conflicts among students while teaching them that voicing their opinions matters, as well as being able to negotiate and compromise.
Need to battle off those creativity killers? Here are 7 simple steps for educators to create a classroom environment that is friendly to creativity.
In this K-2 lesson, students will listen to and/or read Aesop’s time-honored tales to create Greek-inspired theater masks and perform fables. Students will develop insights into human nature and make a connection between ancient Greek culture and their own contemporary culture.
In this 6-8 lesson, students will learn how light interacts with matter through the creation of puppets in shadow plays. Students will examine how light travels and how an object's shadow is affected by the intensity and position of the light in relation to both the object and the surface on which a shadow is cast. This is the first lesson designed to accompany the Shadow Puppet Plays lesson.
In this 9-12 lesson, students will analyze the setting, plot, and character development of Tennessee Williams’s play, A Streetcar Named Desire. They will discuss Williams’s craft as a playwright and his impact on American theater. Students will participate in a group reading and analysis of the play.
In this 3-5 lesson, students will be introduced to the history of square dancing and create a “Kids’ Guide to Square Dancing” media resource. They will learn some basic steps and formations to perform and teach to other children.Â
Generous support for educational programs at the Kennedy Center is provided by the U.S. Department of Education.
Gifts and grants to educational programs at the Kennedy Center are provided by The Paul M. Angell Family Foundation; Bank of America; Capital One; The Morris and Gwendolyn Cafritz Foundation; Carnegie Corporation of New York; The Ednah Root Foundation; Harman Family Foundation; William R. Kenan, Jr. Charitable Trust; the Kimsey Endowment; The Kiplinger Foundation; Laird Norton Family Foundation; Lois and Richard England Family Foundation; Dr. Gary Mather and Ms. Christina Co Mather; The Markow Totevy Foundation; Dr. Gerald and Paula McNichols Foundation; The Morningstar Foundation; Myra and Leura Younker Endowment Fund; The Irene Pollin Audience Development and Community Engagement Initiatives;
Prince Charitable Trusts; Dr. Deborah Rose and Dr. Jan A. J. Stolwijk; Rosemary Kennedy Education Fund; The Embassy of the United Arab Emirates; The Victory Foundation; The Volgenau Foundation; Volkswagen Group of America; Jackie Washington; GRoW @ Annenberg and Gregory Annenberg Weingarten and Family; Wells Fargo; and generous contributors to the Abe Fortas Memorial Fund and by a major gift to the fund from the late Carolyn E. Agger, widow of Abe Fortas. Additional support is provided by the National Committee for the Performing Arts..
The content of these programs may have been developed under a grant from the U.S. Department of Education but does not necessarily represent the policy of the U.S. Department of Education. You should not assume endorsement by the federal government.